In a project that runs across a year-end, or just across several months, the same question comes up every time: how much of the revenue and profit belongs to this period? The amount invoiced is rarely the answer; it is driven by the payment schedule, not by how much work has been done. Percentage-of-completion accounting (in Swedish, successiv vinstavräkning) is the method that instead allocates revenue according to how far the project has come.
This article explains how the method works, how to calculate it, what applies under the Swedish K2 and K3 accounting frameworks, why the final-cost forecast decides everything, and what a monthly follow-up of ongoing projects should look like. The worked examples use made-up figures.
What is percentage-of-completion accounting?
Percentage-of-completion means that the revenue and profit of a fixed-price assignment are recognised as the work is performed, instead of only when the assignment is finished. How much is recognised is governed by the project’s stage of completion: usually costs incurred in relation to the estimated total costs, sometimes hours worked or a measured share of the work done.
The alternative is the completed-contract method: all costs are collected on the balance sheet as work in progress, and the whole revenue and profit are recognised when the assignment is completed. It gives a jerky result (nothing for several periods, everything in one) and says nothing about how the projects are going in the meantime.
For assignments billed by the hour the question is simpler: revenue is recognised as the hours and costs are incurred, regardless of when they are invoiced.
How to calculate: stage of completion and revenue earned
Three formulas are enough:
- Stage of completion = costs incurred / estimated total cost.
- Revenue earned to date = stage of completion × contracted revenue (including ordered change orders, ÄTA).
- Revenue for the period = revenue earned to date − revenue recognised in earlier periods.
An example: a fixed-price project of SEK 10m is estimated to cost SEK 8m. At year-end SEK 6m has been spent.
- Stage of completion: 6 / 8 = 75 per cent.
- Revenue earned: 75 per cent × SEK 10m = SEK 7.5m.
- Profit to date: 7.5 − 6 = SEK 1.5m, regardless of how much has been invoiced.
Invoicing instead decides what ends up on the balance sheet. If SEK 8m has been invoiced according to the payment schedule, SEK 0.5m is “invoiced but not yet earned”, a liability to the customer. If only SEK 6m has been invoiced, SEK 1.5m is “earned but not yet invoiced”, a receivable. Both items are worth following: a growing receivable means you are behind with invoicing, a growing liability that you have invoiced in advance and still have work to deliver.
If the project is expected to make a loss, a special rule applies: the whole estimated loss is recognised immediately, not in step with completion.
K2 or K3: which rules apply?
Which method you may or must use depends on which Swedish accounting framework the company applies:
- K3 (larger companies, and smaller ones that have chosen it): percentage-of-completion is the main rule for fixed-price assignments when the outcome can be estimated reliably. If it cannot, revenue is recognised only up to the costs incurred until the uncertainty is gone.
- K2 (smaller companies): the company may choose between percentage-of-completion (the main rule) and recognising the revenue when the assignment is completed (the alternative rule). The choice must be applied consistently.
The tax rules for work in progress follow the accounting in the main, but not in every detail. Which framework you belong to, how the choice is made and how work in progress is valued at year-end are always things to check with your auditor. This article describes the principles, not your situation.
The final-cost forecast decides everything
Percentage-of-completion is only as good as the forecast of the project’s total cost. That is where it most often goes wrong:
- An over-optimistic forecast. If the estimated total costs are set too low, the stage of completion is too high, revenue is recognised too early and the profit has to be reversed later, often in the same period the project closes and everyone is watching.
- Change orders that are left out. Ordered changes and additions raise both the contracted revenue and the estimated cost. Include the cost but not the revenue, or the other way round, and the stage of completion is wrong.
- Costs incurred but not yet booked. Subcontractor invoices that have not arrived and materials delivered but not invoiced make the stage of completion understated. Accrue them.
- A forecast that is never updated. An estimate from the tender that is still “the forecast” after twelve months is not a forecast. Whoever runs the project should revise the remaining cost every month.
The worked example from the construction project in Gothenburg shows how a final-cost forecast is built line by line from the estimate and the booked actuals, and why time elapsed (67 per cent of the project time has passed) says little about how much of the work is done.
Follow up ongoing projects every month
Percentage-of-completion is in practice a monthly routine, not a year-end question. For every ongoing fixed-price project you should have, every month:
- contracted revenue including ordered change orders,
- costs incurred to date, accrued,
- a revised forecast of the remaining cost, submitted by the project manager,
- stage of completion, revenue earned and profit to date,
- invoiced to date and the item earned but not yet invoiced (or the reverse),
- expected final margin compared with the estimate in the tender.
This takes data from three places: the accounting system (booked costs and invoices), the project system (estimate, change orders, forecast) and the time system (hours worked). As long as they are compiled by hand in a spreadsheet, it is usually done once a year, at year-end, when it is too late to influence the project.
Where does AccuraSee fit in?
AccuraSee calculates the stage of completion, revenue earned and profit per project continuously, with the estimate and change orders from the project system, the costs incurred from the accounting system and the hours from the time system. The project manager sees their projects, the CFO all of them, and every figure can be traced back to the invoice or time entry it comes from. See the examples for construction and professional services.
What AccuraSee does not do: it does not book the revenue recognition for you. The accruals and the valuation of work in progress at year-end are still done in the accounting system, by your finance team or accounting firm, based on the figures the follow-up provides. And the assessment of the remaining cost is and remains the project manager’s. The system makes it visible and comparable, but no better than the person who submits it.
Next step
List your ongoing fixed-price projects and note, for each one, when the forecast of the remaining cost was last revised. If the answer is “at the tender” for more than a couple of them, that is where the risk lies, not in the formulas.
Want to see what follow-up of ongoing projects would look like on your projects? Book a discovery call and we will walk through it on the kind of data you actually work with.